The Easy Way To Thicken Runny Homemade Mayo (2024)

Laura Zbinden

·3 min read

Although mayonnaise was considered a luxury foodwhen it was first created, today this creamy sweet emulsion is thought of as a simple but important everyday condiment. In fact, mayonnaise is one of the most versatile condiments out there, and can be a great addition to salads, sandwiches, and even baked goods. But despite being so engrained in our daily lives, if you've ever tried making mayo at home, you know that it can be more complicated than it appears.

This is because mayonnaise is an emulsion that requires a specific balance of ingredients for it to work. If you don't get your measurements right, or add an ingredient too quickly, your mayo may end up runny. If this happens to you, don't throw the mixture out quite yet -- there is a simple solution: egg yolk. Adding another raw egg yolk and whisking the mixture once again may be all you need to fix your homemade mayonnaise. This works because egg yolk is the ingredient that acts as the glue and helps the whipped oil stay in that light and creamy mayo state.

Read more: 12 Condiments That Don't Need To Be Refrigerated

The Added Egg Yolk Solution

The Easy Way To Thicken Runny Homemade Mayo (1)

The first thing you can do to avoid oily and runny mayo is to start with a good homemade mayonnaise recipe. However, even if you follow the measurements of the recipe to a tee, if you accidentally add the oil too quickly while whisking the emulsion won't form properly and you'll end up with an oily clear liquid instead of a thick white cream.

To fix this, add in another raw egg yolk and start whisking the mixture together. If the mixture starts to thicken after adding the yolk, that means it is working. Once this happens, you should start slowly adding more oil while continuously whisking. You will likely need to add quite a bit more oil and more seasonings because adding another egg yolk is essentially doubling the recipe. Although it sounds counterintuitive, adding more oil can also help thicken the mayonnaise. Also, if you end up with mayo that is too thick, you can always add a little water to thin it down.

However, if you add another egg yolk and the mixture still isn't thickening, then the problem with the mayonnaise was probably nothing to do with the emulsion. It was likely the balance of other ingredients. If that's the case, you can try some thickening methods that don't involve eggs.

Eggless Ways To Thicken Mayonnaise

The Easy Way To Thicken Runny Homemade Mayo (2)

If the egg didn't work to thicken your mayonnaise -- or you are all out of eggs -- don't worry. There are a few other methods you can use to thicken up mayo that isn't cooperating. One option is to use a classic thickener like cornstarch. To do this, combine a little bit of cornstarch with water until it forms a paste and then add it into your runny mayo. Then, whisk the cornstarch together with the mayonnaise to combine and thicken. You can also use arrowroot powder in the same way.

Another option is to add other ingredients that contain natural emulsifiers such as mustard or lemon juice. Add these two ingredients one teaspoon at a time and then keep whisking. Of course, you want to make sure to not add too much lemon juice or mustard as it will change the flavor of your mayonnaise.

Once your delicious homemade mayo is ready, make sure to put it in the fridge where it will thicken up a bit further and stay preserved. Homemade mayo doesn't have the added preservatives that the store-bought version has, so it is important to keep it in the fridge as much as possible.

Read the original article on Daily Meal.

The Easy Way To Thicken Runny Homemade Mayo (2024)

FAQs

The Easy Way To Thicken Runny Homemade Mayo? ›

One option is to use a classic thickener like cornstarch. To do this, combine a little bit of cornstarch with water until it forms a paste and then add it into your runny mayo. Then, whisk the cornstarch together with the mayonnaise to combine and thicken. You can also use arrowroot powder in the same way.

How to thicken runny homemade mayo? ›

A common way to thicken homemade mayonnaise is to gradually add more oil while continuously whisking the mixture. Another method is to add a small amount of dijon mustard, which can help to emulsify the ingredients and give the mayonnaise a thicker consistency.

How do you make mayonnaise more liquid? ›

Solution: Quickly whisk in 5 to 10 ml (1 to 2 teaspoons) of water, vinegar or lemon juice. The mayonnaise will thin out a bit and lose it's oily appareance.

How to thicken store-bought mayonnaise? ›

Additional ways to upgrade store-bought mayo

Although Kewpie uses egg yolks, most brands contain whole eggs, which is why they are thinner. To thicken the mixture without relying on raw egg yolk, stir in a bit of mustard, which is typically used when making mayonnaise from scratch.

What are the thickening agents in mayonnaise? ›

A wide range of water-based gelling and thickening agents are used in mayonnaise products with the most common being modified starch, xanthan gum, and combinations of these. Guar gum, locust bean gum, carrageenan, and gelatin are also applied.

How can I thicken a runny sauce? ›

Use Flour and Water

Combine 2 tablespoons flour with every 1/4 cup cold water and whisk until smooth. Add the mixture to your sauce over medium heat, and continue to stir and cook until you've reached your desired consistency. Test with a spoon.

Why is my Hellmann's mayo runny? ›

Why is my Mayonnaise watery (Hellmanns Separation) Sometimes when jars or bottles have not been used for a while there may be some liquid that appears on the surface of the product. If this does happen, please shake your bottle well, or stir your mayonnaise well before using.

What helps emulsify mayonnaise? ›

Along with the egg yolk, mustard helps emulsify the mixture, reducing the risk of our mayo breaking. Vinegar or lemon juice: Not only does a little acid like wine vinegar, champagne vinegar, and lemon juice add incredible flavor to the mayonnaise, it also helps to stabilize the mixture.

What oil is best for mayonnaise? ›

Use a neutral, refined oil for mayonnaise, such as avocado oil, grapeseed oil, canola oil, sunflower oil, safflower oil, “light” olive oil, or blended oil (a mix of olive and vegetable oils). Do not use unrefined, extra-virgin olive oil, which has a strong flavor and may cause mayonnaise to separate, alone.

Can you over mix homemade mayonnaise? ›

That said it is also a method with little to no margin of error for the consistency; it is completely possible to overmix mayonnaise when making it at such a high speed. If that happens thin it out with water while mixing with a wire whisk.

How to fix too much mayo in deviled eggs? ›

Be sure to add something acidic and spicy to your filling to balance out the richness of the yolks and mayonnaise. Dijon mustard, vinegar, hot sauce, and pickle relish are all good options.

What can I add to mayonnaise to make it taste better? ›

Add to make HERB MAYO: 2 1/2 tbsp chopped herbs(try parsley, chives, dill, tarragon, oregano, thyme, basil). Add to make DILL MAYO: 1/4 cup fresh chopped dill, 1 tbsp lemon juice, 1 tsp garlic, minced and Salt and pepper, to taste. Add to make BLACK PEPPER MAYO: 1 tsp freshly ground black pepper and 1 tsp lemon juice.

What to do when homemade mayonnaise is runny? ›

One option is to use a classic thickener like cornstarch. To do this, combine a little bit of cornstarch with water until it forms a paste and then add it into your runny mayo. Then, whisk the cornstarch together with the mayonnaise to combine and thicken. You can also use arrowroot powder in the same way.

How do you fix too thick mayonnaise? ›

By the time you've added all the oil, you should have a thick, glossy, wobbly mayonnaise that holds its shape. Taste and add more salt, pepper, mustard or vinegar if you like. If the mayonnaise seems too thick, stir in a tablespoon or two of warm water to let it down.

What prevents mayonnaise from separating? ›

Well, mayonnaise contains an extra substance, called an emulsifier, which is used to unite the two immiscible ingredients to form a stable, usable emulsion. The emulsifier is made from a hydrophilic (water-loving) head and a hydrophobic (water-hating) tail, which work together to stop the oil from separating out.

Why is my homemade vegan mayo runny? ›

Important: If mayonnaise doesn't thicken: 1- Start the process by using a small amount of the thin or broken mayonnaise and emulsify with the remaining oil. 2- Add alternately the remaining mixture that has not thicken and oil. 3- Use more oil than the recipe calls for if necessary.

Why is my egg mayo watery? ›

The reason is simply that instead of binding your eggs together with oil and egg yolks — the components of regular mayonnaise — you're instead doing so with a diluted version. Adding more water in the form of light or fat-free mayonnaise necessarily means that more water will seep out of your egg salad.

Is mayonnaise still good if the oil separates? ›

If the oil has separated, that is also a sign that the condiment is no longer good to eat. Other changes in texture, such as thickness or lumps, are also a sign of bad mayonnaise. Expired mayo additionally tends to have a bad smell, often smelling acidic or putrid.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 5955

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.