Why Too Much Mayo Can Ruin Deviled Eggs - Tasting Table (2024)

Why Too Much Mayo Can Ruin Deviled Eggs - Tasting Table (4)

Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock

ByKalea Martin/

If you like hard boiled eggs, there's a good chance you like deviled eggs too. Both start off the same way, and the only difference is that for deviled eggs you remove the yolk and mix in some mayonnaise and seasoning before piping it back onto the egg whites. As far as ingredients go, deviled eggs are simple, but it's for the same reason that the proportions of each one are key.

One of the biggest mistakes you can make, according to Kitchn, is using too much mayonnaise. Too much mayo will seriously overpower the taste of the yolk and, at the same time, it'll also ruin the texture. Remember, the filling gets piped on, and if it's runny it'll be a lot harder to work with.

For best results, The Spruce Eats recommends only three to four tablespoons of mayonnaise per six eggs. The classic recipe also calls for a half teaspoon of mustard, so if you're planning to leave the ingredient out, you have a little more wiggle room.

How to fix deviled eggs with too much mayo

Why Too Much Mayo Can Ruin Deviled Eggs - Tasting Table (5)

Arina P Habich/Shutterstock

So you've already added too much mayo to your deviled egg filling. Now what? The good news is you won't have to start over. The easiest way to go about, Pantry & Larder shares, is to just add more egg yolks. This should get the balance of ingredients back on track. If, however, you've depleted your batch of eggs, there are three other options: breadcrumbs, xanthan gum, and instant mashed potatoes.

In the case that your egg yolk mixture is only slightly runny, breadcrumbs will be your best bet. As Pantry & Larder explains, breadcrumbs work in moderation, so they're ideal when you need just a little extra thickening. If you completely went overboard with the mayo and your egg yolks are soupy, you'll want to opt for xanthan gum instead. A hand blender is necessary for removing the lumps, but it'll definitely do the trick in firming up the mixture. Instant mashed potatoes are a close second to xanthan gum, so if you don't have any, the mash will do well too.

Recommended

Why Too Much Mayo Can Ruin Deviled Eggs - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

Why Too Much Mayo Can Ruin Deviled Eggs - Tasting Table? ›

Too much mayo will seriously overpower the taste of the yolk and, at the same time, it'll also ruin the texture. Remember, the filling gets piped on, and if it's runny it'll be a lot harder to work with. For best results, The Spruce Eats recommends only three to four tablespoons of mayonnaise per six eggs.

What happens if you put too much mayo in deviled eggs? ›

If you add too much mayo, it may overpower the filling and make it runny. For a dozen eggs, ½ cup mayonnaise will make a smooth, creamy filling that can sit up high when spooned into the egg. One way to ensure you get a good yolk-to-mayo ratio is to cook a few extra eggs.

Can you mess up deviled eggs? ›

Making mistakes with deviled eggs can leave you with ugly boiled eggs, eggs that don't taste as good as they should, or even eggs that can make you sick. If you follow the wrong procedure for boiling the eggs or skimp on ingredients, you're not going to end up with a treat that is as good as it could be.

How to get rid of mustard taste in deviled eggs? ›

Add sweetness to your dish. Honey or maple syrup are great choices for counterbalancing mustard, but even just a spoonful of sugar will help.

What causes deviled eggs to get watery? ›

While proper cooking techniques are the first step to avoiding weeping, experimenting with certain deviled egg ingredients, unfortunately, can result in a watery, sloppy appearance on the plate. Ingredients with a high water content, like tomatoes or cucumbers, can help create this wet scenario.

What happens when you have too much mayonnaise? ›

Eating too much mayonnaise can cause high blood pressure problems. Actually, the amount of omega-6 fatty acids in mayonnaise is very high, which can increase blood pressure. Excessive consumption of mayonnaise can also increase the risk of diseases like heart attack and stroke.

How do you get the egg taste out of mayonnaise? ›

Super taster and smeller here- I recommend the addition of garlic or mustard as either will tend to overwhelm the subtle flavor of egg in your mayonnaise. If you're feeling fun, you could make it with yuzu or just purchase some fantastic yuzu mayo.

What are church lady deviled eggs? ›

Disney Springs' Chef Art Smith's Homecoming Church Lady Deviled Eggs are a Southern-inspired delight, boasting creamy yolks blended with tangy mustard, mayo, and a sprinkle of paprika, offering a nostalgic and flavorful twist on a classic appetizer.

How do you fix runny deviled egg filling? ›

To thicken up runny deviled egg filling, adding in some extra egg yolks is the first easy fix to try. This method thickens up the base of the filling without altering the taste.

Why are my deviled eggs rubbery? ›

If you keep the heat turned up too high or too long when you cook an egg, the proteins in the egg white form more and more bonds, squeezing some of the water out of the protein network and making the egg white rubbery.

Why is vinegar added to deviled eggs? ›

Deviled eggs are a naturally rich, decadent food so adding something acidic such as vinegar or lemon juice in the mixture can brighten the flavors and keep them from tasting too rich.

What's a substitute for mustard in deviled eggs? ›

This recipe for Deviled Eggs Without Mustard tastes just like classic deviled eggs but with apple cider vinegar in place of dijon mustard. They're a creamy, delicious appetizer everyone should try!

How do you counteract too much vinegar in deviled eggs? ›

Vinegar is an acid… It makes the food taste sour. I use baking soda, a pinch at a time. The Baking soda is an alkaline product, so the two together will generate carbon dioxide (CO2) and a salt.

Why put paprika on deviled eggs? ›

The paprika will determine the depth of flavor of each bite. You can garnish with any kind (hot or sweet Hungarian, or hot or sweet smoked), but the better the quality, the more complex the flavor.

Why do my eggs taste wet? ›

Scrambled eggs can become watery if they are overcooked or cooked at too high a temperature, causing the proteins to squeeze out moisture. Cooking them gently over low to medium heat and not over-stirring can help prevent excess moisture.

How do you make deviled eggs creamy and not lumpy? ›

The best part of deviled eggs is the creamy filling. And it's at its best when it's super smooth and free of lumps of whole egg yolk. Follow this tip: For a smooth, lump-free filling, use a fork or a potato masher to thoroughly break up the egg yolks before adding the other filling ingredients to the bowl.

Can you over mix mayonnaise? ›

When blended too long, the emulsion that brought the spread together is more likely to break, either from overprocessing or overheating. Follow this tip: To keep the emulsion from breaking and the mayo from separating, process just until the ingredients are combined and emulsified.

How much mayonnaise does it take to equal an egg? ›

Eggs are a key ingredient in mayonnaise, so it makes sense that it can be a perfect substitute when you're out of eggs. Use 3 tablespoons of mayo as an egg substitute.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ms. Lucile Johns

Last Updated:

Views: 6164

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ms. Lucile Johns

Birthday: 1999-11-16

Address: Suite 237 56046 Walsh Coves, West Enid, VT 46557

Phone: +59115435987187

Job: Education Supervisor

Hobby: Genealogy, Stone skipping, Skydiving, Nordic skating, Couponing, Coloring, Gardening

Introduction: My name is Ms. Lucile Johns, I am a successful, friendly, friendly, homely, adventurous, handsome, delightful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.